Skip to main content

    Why Sales & Trading?

    Answer 'Why S&T?' by connecting real markets passion to the nature of the job: fast pace, immediate feedback (daily P&L), and being at the center of macro and market flows. Differentiate from IB — S&T is short feedback loops, intraday decisions, and either client flow (sales) or risk-taking (trading), versus IB's months-long deal processes. Show you follow markets and know which desk fits you.

    Definition

    This question tests whether you genuinely want markets — fast-paced, real-time, P&L-driven work — versus defaulting into S&T because banking didn't work out. The interviewer wants to see authentic interest in markets, an understanding of how S&T differs from IB, and self-awareness about which desk/personality fit you. The headline: you're drawn to the immediacy of markets — real-time decisions, daily P&L feedback, and being plugged into what's moving the world right now.

    What makes a credible 'Why S&T?'

    Authentic reasons that land: (1) You love markets — you follow them daily, have traded (even a small personal account or a simulation), and find macro/asset prices genuinely interesting. (2) Fast feedback loops — you're energized by real-time decisions and a daily P&L scorecard, versus a deal that takes six months to close. (3) Quantitative + quick thinking — you like fast mental math, probabilistic thinking, and staying calm under pressure. Specificity is everything: name a market view or a trade idea, not just 'I like the markets.'

    How S&T differs from IB (know this cold)

    Interviewers want to see you're not using S&T as an IB backup. IB advises on deals (M&A, financing) over months and is relationship/process-driven; S&T operates in real time, where the product is liquidity and risk. Hours differ (S&T is market-hours intense but generally not the all-nighter modeling grind of IB). Skills differ: IB rewards modeling and stamina; S&T rewards quick decisions, market intuition, and risk management. Show you understand and prefer the S&T rhythm.

    Sales vs. Trading — pick a side

    Be clear which you're drawn to. Sales is client-facing: building relationships, pitching trade ideas, providing market color, and connecting clients to liquidity — best if you're personable and a strong communicator. Trading is risk-taking and pricing: making markets, managing a book, and managing risk — best if you're quantitative, decisive, and comfortable with being wrong fast. There's also structuring (designing tailored products). Knowing the distinction signals genuine research.

    Show market fluency

    Nothing proves 'Why S&T?' like demonstrating you actually follow markets. Have a current market view ready ('I think rates are X because Y'), know what major indices/yields/the dollar did recently, and ideally have a simple trade idea with a rationale and a risk. You'll often get 'What's a trade you'd put on right now?' or 'Where do you think [asset] goes?' — this is where stated passion gets verified.

    Tailor to the desk and product

    S&T spans equities, rates, FX, credit, commodities, and derivatives. If you're drawn to a specific asset class, say why — 'I'm most interested in rates because macro policy drives them and I find that interplay fascinating.' Connecting your interest to a specific product and the bank's strengths shows you've thought about fit, not just 'markets in general.'

    Worked Example — With Real Numbers

    "I want to be in S&T because I'm genuinely pulled to markets in real time. I've followed rates and FX closely for the last two years and run a small personal portfolio, and what hooks me is the immediacy — you form a view, put on a position, and the market tells you within hours or days whether you were right. That feedback loop suits how I think far better than a deal process that plays out over months. I'm specifically drawn to trading on the rates desk: I like the macro reasoning, the fast pricing decisions, and managing risk on a live book. As an example, with the curve where it is now, I'd be inclined to [express a view] because [rationale], with my risk being [X]. I know that view could be wrong quickly — and being comfortable with that is part of why the seat appeals to me."

    Key Takeaways

    1

    Connect genuine markets passion to the S&T rhythm: real-time decisions and daily P&L feedback

    2

    Differentiate S&T from IB — short feedback loops and risk/liquidity vs. months-long deals

    3

    Pick a side: sales (client-facing, communication) vs. trading (risk-taking, quantitative)

    4

    Demonstrate market fluency — have a current view and a trade idea ready

    5

    Tailor to a specific desk/asset class and the bank's strengths

    Common Mistakes in Interviews

    Coming across as using S&T as an IB backup with no real markets interest

    Not having a current market view or trade idea when asked

    Confusing sales and trading, or not knowing which you want

    Describing S&T with IB language (deals, models) instead of risk, flow, and P&L

    Generic 'I love the markets' with no specific asset class, view, or evidence

    How Interviewers Test This

    Walk in with a live market view and a simple trade idea, including the risk — interviewers will test whether your 'passion for markets' is real. Be decisive: S&T values people who form a view and commit, not who hedge every sentence. And never frame S&T as a fallback from IB; conviction that you specifically want markets is what gets you the seat.

    Related Concepts

    Directly referenced in this topic

    More Investment Banking

    30 more concepts in this category

    Topic Guides

    Firms That Test This

    Practice Why Sales & Trading? questions

    400+ interview questions with AI feedback. Free to start.

    Start Practicing

    Master Why Sales & Trading? and 100+ More Concepts

    Get the full IB Flash experience and walk into your interview with confidence.

    AI Interview Coach

    Real-time feedback on your answers

    1,000+ Practice Questions

    Across IB, PE, HF, VC & more

    Financial Modeling Tests

    Excel-based skill assessments

    Start Free Trial

    Or explore our free tools to get started