Why Sales & Trading?
Answer 'Why S&T?' by connecting real markets passion to the nature of the job: fast pace, immediate feedback (daily P&L), and being at the center of macro and market flows. Differentiate from IB — S&T is short feedback loops, intraday decisions, and either client flow (sales) or risk-taking (trading), versus IB's months-long deal processes. Show you follow markets and know which desk fits you.
Definition
This question tests whether you genuinely want markets — fast-paced, real-time, P&L-driven work — versus defaulting into S&T because banking didn't work out. The interviewer wants to see authentic interest in markets, an understanding of how S&T differs from IB, and self-awareness about which desk/personality fit you. The headline: you're drawn to the immediacy of markets — real-time decisions, daily P&L feedback, and being plugged into what's moving the world right now.
What makes a credible 'Why S&T?'
Authentic reasons that land: (1) You love markets — you follow them daily, have traded (even a small personal account or a simulation), and find macro/asset prices genuinely interesting. (2) Fast feedback loops — you're energized by real-time decisions and a daily P&L scorecard, versus a deal that takes six months to close. (3) Quantitative + quick thinking — you like fast mental math, probabilistic thinking, and staying calm under pressure. Specificity is everything: name a market view or a trade idea, not just 'I like the markets.'
How S&T differs from IB (know this cold)
Interviewers want to see you're not using S&T as an IB backup. IB advises on deals (M&A, financing) over months and is relationship/process-driven; S&T operates in real time, where the product is liquidity and risk. Hours differ (S&T is market-hours intense but generally not the all-nighter modeling grind of IB). Skills differ: IB rewards modeling and stamina; S&T rewards quick decisions, market intuition, and risk management. Show you understand and prefer the S&T rhythm.
Sales vs. Trading — pick a side
Be clear which you're drawn to. Sales is client-facing: building relationships, pitching trade ideas, providing market color, and connecting clients to liquidity — best if you're personable and a strong communicator. Trading is risk-taking and pricing: making markets, managing a book, and managing risk — best if you're quantitative, decisive, and comfortable with being wrong fast. There's also structuring (designing tailored products). Knowing the distinction signals genuine research.
Show market fluency
Nothing proves 'Why S&T?' like demonstrating you actually follow markets. Have a current market view ready ('I think rates are X because Y'), know what major indices/yields/the dollar did recently, and ideally have a simple trade idea with a rationale and a risk. You'll often get 'What's a trade you'd put on right now?' or 'Where do you think [asset] goes?' — this is where stated passion gets verified.
Tailor to the desk and product
S&T spans equities, rates, FX, credit, commodities, and derivatives. If you're drawn to a specific asset class, say why — 'I'm most interested in rates because macro policy drives them and I find that interplay fascinating.' Connecting your interest to a specific product and the bank's strengths shows you've thought about fit, not just 'markets in general.'
Worked Example — With Real Numbers
"I want to be in S&T because I'm genuinely pulled to markets in real time. I've followed rates and FX closely for the last two years and run a small personal portfolio, and what hooks me is the immediacy — you form a view, put on a position, and the market tells you within hours or days whether you were right. That feedback loop suits how I think far better than a deal process that plays out over months. I'm specifically drawn to trading on the rates desk: I like the macro reasoning, the fast pricing decisions, and managing risk on a live book. As an example, with the curve where it is now, I'd be inclined to [express a view] because [rationale], with my risk being [X]. I know that view could be wrong quickly — and being comfortable with that is part of why the seat appeals to me."
Key Takeaways
Connect genuine markets passion to the S&T rhythm: real-time decisions and daily P&L feedback
Differentiate S&T from IB — short feedback loops and risk/liquidity vs. months-long deals
Pick a side: sales (client-facing, communication) vs. trading (risk-taking, quantitative)
Demonstrate market fluency — have a current view and a trade idea ready
Tailor to a specific desk/asset class and the bank's strengths
Common Mistakes in Interviews
Coming across as using S&T as an IB backup with no real markets interest
Not having a current market view or trade idea when asked
Confusing sales and trading, or not knowing which you want
Describing S&T with IB language (deals, models) instead of risk, flow, and P&L
Generic 'I love the markets' with no specific asset class, view, or evidence
How Interviewers Test This
Walk in with a live market view and a simple trade idea, including the risk — interviewers will test whether your 'passion for markets' is real. Be decisive: S&T values people who form a view and commit, not who hedge every sentence. And never frame S&T as a fallback from IB; conviction that you specifically want markets is what gets you the seat.
Related Concepts
Directly referenced in this topic
Why Investment Banking
'Why investment banking?' is the **core motivation question** in every IB interv...
Beta (Finance)
Beta measures the systematic risk (market risk) of a stock relative to the overa...
Merger Arbitrage
Merger arbitrage (also called risk arbitrage) is an event-driven hedge fund stra...
Long/Short Equity
Long/short equity is a hedge fund investment strategy that involves buying (goin...
Short Selling
Short selling is the practice of selling a security that the seller does not own...
Cost of Capital
Cost of capital is the minimum return a company must generate to satisfy everyon...
More Investment Banking
30 more concepts in this category
Topic Guides
Firms That Test This
Practice Why Sales & Trading? questions
400+ interview questions with AI feedback. Free to start.
Start PracticingMaster Why Sales & Trading? and 100+ More Concepts
Get the full IB Flash experience and walk into your interview with confidence.
AI Interview Coach
Real-time feedback on your answers
1,000+ Practice Questions
Across IB, PE, HF, VC & more
Financial Modeling Tests
Excel-based skill assessments
Or explore our free tools to get started